Dining Options on Fire Island

A weekend getaway can help you unwind and recharge. Consider planning a trip to Fire Island to sit back, relax, and treat yourself. Here are some dining options for your stay on Fire Island:

Castaway Bar and Grill is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat on Fire Island. Check out this restaurant for a variety of menu options, including calamari, chicken fingers, and steak. Consider the Banh Mi sandwich made with pork, pickled vegetables, cilantro, and dashi mayo. You can also order the scallop scampi, which is made with udon noodles and toasted parmesan panko. Castaway Bar and Grill also serves tagliatelle pasta, chicken chicharrones, char siu pork belly, and more.

You can visit Rachel's Fire Island Restaurant and Bakery for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The breakfast menu includes Rachel's famous bran pancakes, omelets, egg sandwiches, avocado toast, and children's options. The lunch menu features burritos, fried calamari, salads, and burgers, and the dinner menu has paella, baked acorn squash, eggplant parmigian, steak, flounder, and more.

What better cuisine to enjoy during a stay on Fire Island than seafood? Visit Matthews Seafood for a seafood cobb salad, crispy fried shrimp, broiled filet of sole, and more. Matthews Seafood also has a kid's menu and a cocktail menu.

These restaurants are just some of the best places to grab a bite to eat during your stay on Fire Island. To book your room for your next vacation, give us a call at the Fire Island Boatel. You can reach us at 833-342-6283. You can also book your reservation on our website. We look forward to seeing you during your stay!