The Kismet Inn — 1 Oak Street, Kismet, NY 11706

The Kismet Inn is a local tavern that has been around since 1925, serving burgers and seafood both indoors and outdoors. The inn also offers live music during evenings as well as a full bar.

Surf's Out — 1 Bay Walk, Kismet, NY 11706

The Surf's Out, located just steps away from the Fire Island Boatel, is open for both lunch and dinner serving sushi, seafood, and American classics. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating, and also offers local delivery. We recommend the "Rocket Fuel," a Fire Island classic!

Fire Island Tap — 177 Pine Street, Kismet, NY 11706

Fire Island Tap is a local cafe serving coffee, craft beer, and wine. They have the best fresh brewed coffee and pastries in town, and also serve charcuterie plates that are available for local delivery. Visit their Facebook page or follow them on Instagram at @fireislandtap for more information.

Pizza Shack of Kismet — 21 East Lighthouse Walk, Kismet, NY 11706

The Pizza Shack of Kismet, located just steps away from the Fire Island Boatel, offers two walk-up windows: one serving pizza, and another serving Italian ices and soft serve ice cream. The Pizza Shack also has picnic-style outdoor seating available.

Le Dock Restaurant — 60 Bay Walk, Fair Harbor, NY 11706

Le Dock Restaurant is a local favorite serving seafood, cocktails, and wine, located just under one and a half miles away from the Fire Island Boatel, in Fair Harbor. Guests can walk, bike, or take the Fire Island Water Taxi to and from the restaurant, which offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery to Kismet is also available. Reservations for Le Dock Restaurant are recommended, and can be made through OpenTable. 

Michael's Pizzeria — 60 Bay Walk, Fair Harbor, NY 11706

Michael's Pizzeria is located directly behind Le Dock Restaurant, offering takeout only pizza pies. To place an order, call (631) 583-5200.